
FRESH STUFF DAILY
Seacoast New Hampshire
& South Coast Maine
Subscribe To Our Newsletter
|
|
| |
|
|
|
10dd
cialia or viagro buy viagra cheap canada viagra cialis generic cialisis canada cheapest med where to buy fenfluramine cialis mg vicodine canada viagra buy viagra online canada canada cheapest med what is the best online pharmacy for viagra pharmacy canada cheap online viagra get viagra prescription online buy viagra online no prescription no prescription zoloft canada pharmacy viagra viagra sale buy propecia viagra sale cheapest daily cialis cialis or viagra online pharmacy to buy phentermine cialis generic cialis 5 mg buy 5mg propecia usa propecia with out a prescription viagracanadianpharmacy buy zoloft generic online viagra prescription pharmacy levitra sales online
0
|
The Beast of Smuttynose
|
|
|
|
Written by Smuttynose History
|
|
SMUTTYNOSE MURDERS
We’re always on the lookout for more views of the famous shoals murders. This August 1964 pulp account illustrates why you just can’t trust those cheesy detective magazines for facts. Long before Americans got a steady diet of lurid murder tales on HDTV, crime periodicals were in their heyday.
Isles of Shoals History as Pulp Fiction
The Beast of Smutty Nose
By William Beeson
Front Page Detective / Dell Magazines
August 1964
MORE on the murders
Besides the trial transcript, there are few reliable accounts of the 1873 Smuttynose Murders. Contemporary newspaper articles were peppered with inaccuracies. Pulp magazines like this one from Front Page Detective recycled the story of Louis Wagner largely as told by poet Celia Thaxter in 1875 and later by murder reporter Edmund Pearson in 1926. Both of those authors were unequivocally convinced that Louis Wagner murdered two women on Smuttynose Island, and was rightfully hanged for his crime.
This pulp detective version, probably written for pennies a word, follows in that tradition. But like many later accounts, this author clearly never visited Smuttynose Island or dug very deeply into the story. Author William Beeson begins dramatically:
"Nothing human could row so far in stormy seas – except a man inhumanly possessed by visions of hoarded gold and lovely girls left alone on a barren island."

Beeson’s narrative is reasonably accurate in the description of the crime, although he notes early that the murder house was the only house on the island. That was not, and has never been true. Then as the story unfolds, Beeson gets more and more details wrong. The mystery for a modern researcher, is where Besson got his false facts. He notes, for example, that Louis Wagner stole $200, when he, in fact, got only $16 from the house on Smuttynose. Beeson goes further and further off the mark with the timeline of the murders of Karen and Anethe. He notes, for example, that Louis Wagner attended the funerals of the victims in Portsmouth and introduces a series of alternative murder suspects not known to historians.
Beeson says that investigator’s found a Prussian medallion clutched in Karen Christiansen’s dead hand, pointing to Wagner, the Prussian fisherman, as the killer. Beeson says Wagner rowed back to Portsmouth and, to provide an alibi, went to work with fisherman John Hontvet at 3 a.m. that morning, unloading bait from a train. All of these and many other "facts" in the article are false. Did the author find these stories somewhere else or simply make them up? Beeson clearly never saw the detailed account of the "Moonlight Murder" by Shoals historian Lyman Ruttledge (1958) that offers the best researched essay available. Anita Shreve, however, did use the booklet by Ruttledge to craft her own fictional version of the story in her best selling novel Weight of Water. -- JDR
|
Please visit these SeacoastNH.com ad partners.
Portsmouth Herald
|
Portsmouth Herald Latest Headlines
|
| Portsmouth Herald News from SeacoastOnline.com |
-
UNH hockey powers past Terriers
DURHAM — The play of the University of New Hampshire men's hockey team special teams looked, well, special, Friday night against Boston University.
-
NFL's premier corner Revis mans up on Moss again
FLORHAM PARK, N.J. — Darrelle Revis has heard enough about his last matchup with Randy Moss. The New York Jets cornerback just wants to move on to the next one.
-
Father-son coaches creating legacy with Winnacunnet football
HAMPTON — If nothing else, Winnacunnet High School has proven that two Steve Magris are better than one when it comes to coaching football.
-
Bergeron wins it for B's in OT
BUFFALO, N.Y. (AP) — Patrice Bergeron scored with 47 seconds left in overtime, lifting the Boston Bruins to a 2-1 win over the Buffalo Sabres on Friday night.
-
Emotional home finale for UNH football
DURHAM — One year ago this week, University of New Hampshire strong safety Terrence Klein intercepted two late passes to preserve a snowy 28-24 win at Maine, more proof that...
-
Carter, Magic drop Celtics
BOSTON — Vince Carter scored 26 points, Rashard Lewis had 16 points and 10 rebounds, and the Orlando Magic beat the Boston Celtics 83-78 on Friday night.
-
Portsmouth says stimulus jobs overstated by White House
PORTSMOUTH — While federal stimulus dollars flowing into the city may help both causes and the economy, at least one local project echoes concerns expressed nationwide about the accuracy of...
-
Joseph Popluhar
TAMPA, Fla. — Mr. Joseph Popluhar, 71, of Tampa, formerly of Portsmouth, N.H., beloved husband of Marjorie (Hunt) Popluhar, died Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2009, in Florida.
-
Turkey Trot 5K in Portsmouth on Thanksgiving morning
PORTSMOUTH — Thanksgiving is one of the most charitable times of the year. If you're in the giving mood, why not get a little exercise, too?
-
Marshwood Middle School parents told 58 of 60 kids accepted unknown Facebook friend
ELIOT, Maine — Marshwood Middle School parents were shocked to learn from Internet expert Jayne Hitchcock Thursday evening that 58 of 60 middle school honors students accepted her as a...
-
Newington tax rate drops, but selectman chides state lawmakers
NEWINGTON — Town taxpayers will pay a lower tax rate for 2009, but the chairman of the Board of Selectmen announced the good news with some concerns for state politicians.
-
Memorial Bridge re-opens
PORTSMOUTH — The Memorial Bridge reopened ahead of schedule on Friday following a month of repairs that forced motorists to seek alternative routes between the city and Kittery, Maine.
-
Bakers bustling for Sunday's pie festival
GREENLAND — Judy Alix laughed excitedly. "Thirty made, only 470 more to go!" she exclaimed.
-
3-car crash on Woodbury Ave.
PORTSMOUTH — A three-car, chain-reaction crash snarled lunch hour traffic Friday on Woodbury Avenue and sent a Maine man to Portsmouth Regional Hospital.
-
Thumbs up to preservation, determination
Thumbs up to the heirs of Mary McIntire Davis for selling a 239-acre parcel of salt marsh and forest along the York River to the York Land Trust ,and to...
-
John R. Genthner
HAMPTON FALLS — John Richard Genthner, born Jan. 28, 1943, in St. John, New Brunswick, Canada, died peacefully Thursday, Nov. 19, 2009, after a long illness. He was surrounded by...
-
Runner's Alley helps racer achieve her goals
I would like to thank Janine and the staff at Runner's Alley for their great work in this community. Their contribution, enthusiasm and encouragement are a shining example of what...
-
New Generation raises $10,000 with golf tourney
The New Generation Golf tournament was held at Breakfast Hill Golf Club. With the help of all those who supported it, we made more than $10,000.
-
Memorial is a N.H. bridge; Herald must act to save it
Sitting a couple of hundred miles up the Maine coast, there isn't anyone who knows or cares about our bridge. They've got their own big-time problems that aren't getting fixed.
-
Robert F. Pucciarelli
WELLS, Maine — Robert Francis "Bob" Pucciarelli, 83, of Wells, formerly of Medway, Mass., died early Thursday morning, Nov. 19, 2009.
|
|
|
|
|
| Saturday, November 21, 2009 |
|
|
|